Welcome! This is a blog that generally covers issues related to health and development economics. Feel free to visit and comment as often as you'd like.
Tuesday, July 31, 2007
Parking
Unfortunately, both the roads (number and quality) and parking spots (number) have not kept pace with these changes. As a result, its a real hassle to find parking in the city centers. People end up parking anywhere they please and that disrupts the already unruly traffic.
In this situation, what is completely baffling is the fact that the city-set price for parking has not changed appreciably in a very long time. In most areas of Chennai it is free and in some of the city centers, its about Rs. 10 for an entire day (less than $1 in purchasing power terms). In a normal functioning market, you'd expect the price of parking to increase since supply has remained the same and demand has increased. (I would also argue that the market clearing price of parking should reflect externalities conferred on other drivers, such as the annoyance of having to walk an extra two blocks to get to the Music Academy and the disruption of traffic on the still-thin roadways).
At some point, the city government needs to charge more for parking. Rs 10 is well below the market clearing price and it really sucks right now to park, drive, get anywhere in the city.
Thursday, July 26, 2007
On Height
In Blink, Malcolm Gladwell points out that men over six feet tall are more than disproportionately represented among the ranks of Fortune 500 CEOs. He attributes this to something called the “Warren Harding Error,” where individuals make a positive or negative snap-judgment based on physical attributes. In this case, Gladwell claims that we subconsciously attach positive attributes - competence, bravery and other niceties - to height. (The Warren Harding reference speaks to the fact that these snap judgments can be quite wrong. At least with respect to height, for every James Hudspeth there is a Warren Harding. The former is one sharp bloke; the latter was the one of the worst presidents the
Wednesday, July 25, 2007
Review: Icky Thump, White Stripes
Never mind.
Icky Thump is the latest offering in the series of earnest, stripped-down, fun rock-n-roll albums put out by the Stripes. Do you like primal drumbeats, power chords, great lyrics and good variety? How about all that with bagpipes? If you answered yes to the above, you need to listen to this album!
I've been through about 10 listens of this album so far, in locations as diverse as Heathrow airport, the metro in Copenhagen, during a run on Chennai beach, and while getting lost and traversing through an urban slum. For some reason, Thump provided an appropriate soundtrack for each of these experiences, though there is no a priori reason why anyone would think this would be possible.
I think part of the reason Thump works so well is the combination of deep lyrics and the variety. The latter is simply remarkable. Heavy-ish songs like Bone Broke, Little Cream Soda, Rag and Bone are both up-tempo and introspective all at once. These are set against equally introspective but considerably lighter versions, the favorites of mine being 300 MPH Torrential Outpour Blues and Prickly Thorn, But Sweetly Worn. The latter sounds like a Scottish folk-tune.
Of course, the title song, describing an interesting trip through Mexico (see the youtube video!) is phenomenal. My favorite verse is the following:
Well, Americans: What, nothin' better to do?
Why don't you kick yourself out?
You're an immigrant too.
Who's usin' who?
What should we do?
Well you can't be a pimp
And a prostitute too
One could easily imagine this being directed at those curmudgeony and ultimately silly Senate Republicans who oppose the President's stance on immigration.
I give this album 8.5/10. Go listen to it....NOW!
Monday, July 23, 2007
Harry Potter and the Ruined Suspense
-Harry gets bored of saving the world and decides to become a professional quidditch player in the United States. He does a commercial with Lebron James, marries a supermodel and gets blue contact lenses. Sadly, he no longer has his mother's eyes.
-Hermione decides she is way too good for Ron and unceremoniously dumps him for Harry. Harry refuses and Hermione becomes the Prime Minister of England.
-Voldemort beats Harry and uses the spoils of war to fund a huge NGO that distributes ARVs to HIV/AIDS patients in Africa.
I figured that, even if the ending was spoiled for me, I'd still be excited read the book. After all, I can watch the same Super Bowl over and over and over even though I know the outcome and score. For some reason though, I am completely indifferent now as to when I read this book. Yuck.
Friday, July 20, 2007
Kanchipuram Saris, Child Labor and Development
The sari salesman pointed out that these developments may have had adverse impacts on his trade. Sari weaving skills are passed down from generation to generation. However, for the youngest generation, the opportunity cost for investing in sari weaving skills has become very high: jobs in the service and growing manufacturing sector are growing in number and offer better lifetime returns to human capital investments. Because such jobs require schooling, the incidence of child labor in the state has declined as well, since returns to education, real or perceived, have increased. Because much of the Kanchipuram silk industry relies on child labor, this is bad for the trade.
It's an interesting story about how traditional arts and skills are fundamentally affected by economic development. The sari salesman seemed to think that, within a few years, Kanchipuram saris would cease to exist. I'm not so sure how this will play out, but here are a few thoughts:
-I wonder if sari manufacturers are offering higher wages to draw in labor. Similarly, I wonder if these costs are being passed on to consumers.
-How do we value the loss of traditional values and arts in the context of economic development? If people begin to value these goods less through the market and as a result of development, is there anything to worry about? Should these aspects be included in computing an overall development GDP in the same way various parties suggest we include improvements in life expectancy or happiness?
Praise
"I think 'Dar he Blogs' is one of the best blogs I've ever seen. Nobody is blogging this often and this well right now. I recently talked to some of the pioneers of blogging and they agreed.
Also, I think the font used in 'Dar he Blogs' is the best font ever. I recently talked to Gutenberg, the guy who made type-set fonts possible, and he agreed that very few blogs use fonts so effectively. I really love this blog."
(credit to the Sportsguy)
Harry Potter Mania
It turns out that I succeeded. There are a few large bookstores here, with Landmark and Higginbotham's among the most popular. Anticipating huge lines, I scouted out smaller bookstores and found a Higginbotham's satellite store about 0.5 km from where I am staying. A few days of observation revealed that crowds (on a typical day) were minimal. I found my target.
I got up this morning around 6 AM to go wait in line for the book. I head to the store and....no line. Not only that, I was the only one in the store! Everyone else had pre-ordered their copies and I was able to get an unclaimed copy for myself..it was almost too easy.
There is one small disappointment: I was kind of looking forward to exchanging elbows with Indian parents and their children while fighting for a coveted copy of the book.
(Ed: I will NOT talk about the 7th book until Jan 2008, so as not to spoil the ending for anyone. See? We at the blog care about YOU)
Thursday, July 19, 2007
A Day in the Life
Yesterday was a typical day. I started off at the Government of Tamil Nadu, oscillating between the Department of Social Welfare, Planning Commission and World Bank ICDS (Integrated Child Development Services) offices. The great thing about Tamil Nadu is that high-level officials are extremely accessible. I literally walked into the Secretary of Social Welfare's and Member Secretary of the Planning Commissions' offices yesterday to ask a few questions! Imagine trying to do that in a typical U.S. state goverment. Heck, I probably couldn't drop in on the Town of Clifton Park Supervisor's office that easily!
I think a lot of this comes from the recent nationwide push to make government more accessible/accountable to the people. In fact, the Right to Information Act which I am using for leverage in getting data is another initiative in this broader scheme.
Everyone in government is nice and willing to help. Unfortunately, it is still difficult to extract the needed historical information. Apparantly, it is computerized somewhere...but not really. And each official claims that the other one has the information I need....but when I head to that individual, I get returned to sender.
All in all, I think I shuttled between departments three times yesterday, taking the city train back and forth. Like a fool, I didn't take a bottle of water with me, and paid the price for being out in the sun later at night when my body completely shut down.
The afternoon session was much better. I visited the Institute for Financial and Management Research (IFMR) on a tip from Santosh Anagol (do visit his blog, "Brown Man's Burden"), and found it absolutely exhilarating. They are doing all sorts of interesting research there, much of it in conjunction with U.S. economists. A lot of their work has to do with coming up with various poverty reduction schemes and testing these in the real world using randomized experiments. Because its applied, the research is policy relevant and useful for public and private organizations alike. In addition, the investigators try to incorporate questions in their survey that will allow the measurement of outcomes and behaviors that are useful in testing/building economic theory.
Here is an example of an applied problem they work with. Imagine two neighboring farmers. Neither is rich enough, or has enough access to credit, to make a capital investment in a bore-well that could be used for irrigation. Collectively they do have enough to carry this out. However, despite generations of their family living and tilling that land, no contract or transaction is made between the two parties to undertake this investment. It seems that farmers are unwilling to enter joint-liability situations (where would the bore-well be placed, does placement matter in who is in charge of upkeep, etc?). Rather, they are more willing to buy water from a neighboring farmer who already has a bore-well; that too, not through a long-term agreement, but through daily spot transactions. How can we encourage efficient investment and low-opportunity cost financial contracts? What sort of financial instruments are appropriate for this situation? These are the sorts of questions the IFMR deals with.
My visit was to find out more about what they do in the public health and micro-healthinsurance areas. I won't know about that until next week, when I visit another branch of the IFMR. I'm excited for the next visit and will surely keep you informed.
Tuesday, July 17, 2007
Midday Meals
I'm here for the purposes of my dissertation. I'm writing three papers on "The Economics of Child Health" and one of these will be on studying the health and education effects of large scale nutritional programs in developing countries. One of the most famous programs is administered right here in the state of Tamil Nadu. In 1982, motivated by a mixture of compassion (hopefully) and electoral populism (more likely), then Chief Minister MG Ramachandran put in place a program designed to offer a free lunch to all children aged 2-9, 365 days of the year. A year later, this program was extended to children 10-15 and elderly pensioners.
The anecdotal success of the program has spurred the Government of India at large to mandate all states to implement similar programs. (As yet, not all states have instituted such programs - the political economy of this policy lag is another paper waiting to be written perhaps). In addition, the Tamil Nadu Midday Meals program has motivated other countries to think about developing similar schemes, as well. This is a big deal both politically and fiscally: in Tamil Nadu, at least, this program takes up a sizeable chunk of the social welfare budget. However, there is little empirical evidence documenting the causal effects of the program on nutrition and schooling. Whatever few studies exist have trouble distinguishing between program effects and secular trends in economic development in the state (increase per capita income, better infrastructure, etc).
The aim of my project is to investigate this question more thoroughly. For a variety of reasons, this is going to be very challenging:
-The program is not a randomized experiment, and was implemented all at once across the state. Hence, there is little cross-sectional (i.e., spatial) variation that can be used to identify treatment effects.
-Data on program availability by village is almost necessary in order to develop convincing evidence. Unfortunately, either this evidence does not exist, or it is impossible to get thanks to politics (see below).
My main approach is to milk discontinuities in age eligibility and the timing of the program in order to estimate the causal effects. For example, individuals between the age of 1.5-2 are not eligible for the program, while those aged 2-2.5 are. One can use this information to compare kids in each age group to see if there is a nutritional effect. Of course, if families redistribute resources amongst kids, this comparison becomes much more complicated. Another example: I can look at long term effects, using the fact that individuals of different birth years were exposed to varying lengths of the treatment. This is true because the program came into existence in 1982, and eligibility requirements were changed in different years.
Because its so hard to get data on program center locations, I also have some backup questions, which involve studying the effects of meal programs at an all-India level (much easier from the econometrics point of you), and studying a different health and nutrition program aimed at children aged 0-6 for which there is ample cross-sectional and time series variation both within Tamil Nadu and at the all India level.
About getting data: I went over to the Tamil Nadu Planning Commission and the Department of Social Welfare offices to make my data request. Through the 2005 Right to Information Act, any information request must be addressed within 30 days. Of course, when I went over, I was told that the task was impossible and that the data I need doesn't exist, even at a district (equiv to counties in the U.S) level. I know that this is not true because other researchers (who don't like to share) have used the district level information. I was told later by an academic contact that because the program is heavily politicized, government officials are loathe to give out detailed information. I am making another attempt today, so we'll see.
Sunday, July 15, 2007
Celebrity sightings and pics
What is it that draws celebrities to me? My 'Italian good looks'? Incredible charisma? Random chance?
The world may never know.