Welcome! This is a blog that generally covers issues related to health and development economics. Feel free to visit and comment as often as you'd like.
Saturday, June 25, 2011
Random Links
2. Chris Blattman on a great new paper linking weather disturbances/changes faced early in life to long-run outcomes. He makes some great points about the mechanisms underlying these relationships as well as appropriate practices for statistical work when researchers have abundant data points but little theory guiding exactly what the relationship between two variables might be.
3. Some time ago, I wrote about tennis rackets, lamenting the disappearance of one model in particular as if it were a lost love. Apparently, that tone was appropriate since the racket a pro tennis player chooses seems to say a lot about their personality and preferences - at least as it relates to the tennis court . (Hat tip: MG)
4. I just found out that Sanjay Basu, an MD/PhD epidemiologist doing an internal medicine residency at UCSF, has a great thing going with his new(-ish) blog, epianalysis. Sanjay has got to be one of the most talented, insightful and prolific researchers around. His work spans the mathematical modeling of infectious diseases that incorporate insights from fields as diverse as economics and epidemiology, all the way to deep political economy issues related to global health. He's produced a body of work while in residency that I would be proud of if it formed the entirety of my research career. Seriously. His blog is phenomenal and highly recommended. (Hat tip: PC)
Wednesday, September 16, 2009
How the Steelers Can Win An Additional Game this Season
Interestingly, the most intriguing analysis of the year to date has come from a pair of economists, which includes Steve Levitt of Freakonomics fame. They write:
Game theory makes strong predictions about how individuals should behave in two player, zero sum games. When players follow a mixed strategy, equilibrium payoffs should be equalized across actions, and choices should be serially uncorrelated. Laboratory experiments have generated large and systematic deviations from the minimax predictions. Data gleaned from real-world settings have been more consistent with minimax, but these latter studies have often been based on small samples with low power to reject. In this paper, we explore minimax play in two high stakes, real world settings that are data rich: choice of pitch type in Major League Baseball and whether to run or pass in the National Football League. We observe more than three million pitches in baseball and 125,000 play choices for football. We find systematic deviations from minimax play in both data sets. Pitchers appear to throw too many fastballs; football teams pass less than they should. In both sports, there is negative serial correlation in play calling. Back of the envelope calculations suggest that correcting these decision making errors could be worth as many as two additional victories a year to a Major League Baseball franchise, and more than a half win per season for a professional football team.
Interesting stuff. I wonder if this article will garner as much controversy as a piece written a few years back by economist David Romer, whose analysis suggested that NFL teams play a risk-averse, sub-optimal strategy when punting the football outside of their own red zone.
Tuesday, January 13, 2009
Innovation and the NFL
I just read a great article about Florida phenom Tim Tebow and his probability of success in the NFL. What was different about this piece than say similar ones about Peyton Manning, Reggie Bush, etc, is the sense that Tebow brings a unique and possibly unprecedented skill set to the NFL that may not have been valued in the past but could have enormous returns as the game evolves.
The piece reminds me of a great book a read a few months ago, The Blind Side: The Evolution of a Game by Michael Lewis. The book chronicles the story of Ole Miss left tackle Michael Oher, who's rise to prominence from a poor, homeless child in and out of school to potential draft day stud was written in the stars years before his birth, with the exogenous introduction of Lawrence Taylor into the NFL. Taylor was such a special player that his rise to prominence raised the returns to having a freakishly gifted athlete guarding a quarterback's "blind side" (i.e., for right handed QBs, it would the left tackle). The increased returns were reflected in the market value of left tackles: NFL wages was artificially depressed until the early 1990s, when the era of free agency lifted the constraints on wages. At this juncture, the wages of left tackles increased precipitously.
I highly recommend The Blind Side, and not just for the economics.
Thursday, October 16, 2008
I'm Fired!
But, I look at my lifetime record (I average about a 6th place finish out of 12 teams) and realized that there is likely a persistent component to my lack of titles and general mediocrity. I also noticed that Yahoo! Fantasy Football has a new feature where people can co-manage a single fantasy team.
Given all this, I've decided to fire myself as the general manager of my team, and outsource the responsibilities of drafting and early season waiver-wire moves to someone else. I will still retain final authority over decision-making and retain the capacity to make some moves myself, but all of this will be in a much reduced role.
My firing of myself is effective immediately. I am currently looking for someone with at least five years of fantasy football experience (from competitive leagues, with a successful track record) to take over the GM role of the team. Let me know if you are interested.
Sunday, May 18, 2008
Great Article on Shen Tennis
Anyway, today's Albany Times Union has a great article about Shen's starting third doubles player who, due to several congenital anomalies, plays and wins without most of his fingers, toes, and the ability to see out of his right eye. A really great story.
Also, the article quotes Gene Gould, Shen's longtime coach. It's great to see him still at the helm, coaching so many championship level teams.
Sunday, April 27, 2008
Cheerleaders in India
An interesting feature of the IPL is the presence of cheerleaders. During the opening weekend of league play, the Washington Redskin cheerleaders did a dance number for shocked/delighted Indian crowds. Following their lead, each team has its own set of cheerleaders, who dance around the boundaries in the same fashion as NFL cheerleaders do on the sidelines.
In Saturday's matches, I was surprised to note that the cheerleaders wore extremely revealing outfits. The exception were the Chennai Super King girls who, reflecting the still traditional ethos of the city, were fully clothed. However, during today's matches, cheerleaders for the Mumbai Indians covered their midriffs and legs and those for the opposing Deccan Chargers went a step further and wore reasonably demure Indian-style outfits.
Why the change? Apparently, the cheerleaders have caused quite a stir among conservatives in India, who find the whole concept "vulgar."
I find the whole hullabaloo to be ridiculous. Here's why:
1) I think Indians have a skewed concept of vulgarity. How are cheerleaders in short skirts more vulgar than the content of a typical Hindi movie, with all the gyrating and suggestive imagery/lyrics? It's pretty hypocritical for high level ministers to run around and comment on cheerleading when the very elements the criticize are present in their own region's media.
2) In the link posted above, one of the cheerleaders comments:
"We do expect people to pass lewd, snide remarks but I am shocked by the nature and magnitude of the comments people pass here (in India)" cheerleader Tabitha from Uzbekistan said.
"Be it a 70-year-old or a 15-year-old kid they all letch at us and make amorous advances.
"We are living in constant fear of being molested," she bemoaned.
Sadly, this is an experience shared by many women I know (especially foreigners) who have either traveled through or lived in India for some period of time. My running theory is that this can be chalked up to repression. Short of a large scale cultural education in how to treat women (which is definitely needed in many parts of the world), perhaps the very presence of cheerleaders can go so distance in lowering the "shock value" of sexuality in India, thus helping quell the kinds of wolfish behaviors that happen in regimes of repression.Thursday, January 24, 2008
Post-Football Funk
The post-NFL funk last about a month for me, at the end of which the inevitable March madness comes by to get my spirits up again. As such, February is my least favorite month of the year, and I estimate that my mood and productivity both tank during this time.
I wonder if this holds more generally across the population of football fans. Almost everyone I know feels depressed after the NFL (or college) seasons. Does this have consequences for their health, productivity and happiness, too? How important are these consequences to population health and the economy at large?
I don't think anyone has done a study on this yet. Obviously, establishing causality would be difficult. You'd need some kind of before and after Super Bowl measurement(s) on these various outcomes among NFL fans as well as a control group to difference out general non-NFL trends (like "wow, I'm a bit sick of winter now", etc). But finding a control group would be hard. I'd suggest NBA fans, but they are a little weird.
Cleaner identification is possible by looking fans of opposing teams playing each other in a single-elimination game. For example, an enterprising soul could look at Patriots and Giants fans before and after the Super Bowl. This article uses a similarly themed strategy for soccer matches and finds that Premier League home team losses are associated with increased incidence of death due to acute myocardial infarctions and strokes.
With the Steelers out of the playoffs, my arch enemies the Patriots poised to go undefeated, and eight months of no NFL in front of me, I am poised to have a pretty dumb February.
But what's that? Duke basketball in the top 5? Maybe the funk will be tempered somewhat.
Wednesday, January 16, 2008
"Football Guy"
In case you are wondering, my cousin used Paintbrush to create this picture. Given that program's inherent limitations and finickiness, this makes her accomplishment even more remarkable.
To hear more about my cousin, in particular her ambitions to become a princess, see here.
Wednesday, December 19, 2007
Asterisks of Gall(?)
1) The Blame Game - People have been quick to vilify some of the players named in the Mitchell report as cheaters. For some of the bigger names, such as Roger Clemens, the buzz surrounds whether or not they should be inducted to the Baseball Hall of Fame or not. I am having a tougher time burning effigies of these players. Why? Because they aren't the real culprits behind baseball's "steroid era."
Here is my take. Suspicion of widespread use of steroids and other drugs was growing as early as the late 1980s and early 1990s. Major League Baseball did not take any steps as far as stringent testing and penalties until over a decade later. In the meantime, the use of performance enhancers likely lead to increases in wages and length of tenure for the average player. Given the low level of deterrence and potentially large expected benefits, players went for steroids and HGH, their preferences for health and discount rates notwithstanding. Perhaps there were even externalities from usage: a single player or groups of players performing better and accruing higher wage earnings likely upped the ante for everyone else to performance better, further tipping the cost/benefit balance over to usage.
In any case, the MLB did nothing for a really long time. Not only that, post the strike induced lock-out in the early 1990s, the game was essentially "saved" in the eyes of paying fans by the steroid induced home run chase in the summer of 1998. The MLB's inaction and their packaging of the game in terms of increased power hitting and speed likely created the right kind of incentives to induce the marginal player into trying to get the extra boost.
2) Asterisks - Putting asterisks on records held by suspected users of performance enhancing drugs seems like a difficult proposition to me. If the Mitchell Report is indeed the tip of the iceberg, and use of agents like anabolic steroids and HGH was (and is) widespread, it is hard to distinguish between "legit" and "cheater-induced" records and probably unwise to try and do so. Rather, interpretation of statistics should be left up to discerning fans.
Still like asterisks? Given the discussion in (1), try this one: MLB*.
3) "Steroids don't help you ______" - Some players and analysts claim that performance enhancing drugs do not really help you become a better baseball player. Two supporting arguments are generally cited. First, steroids and HGH do not help you develop the mechanics to hit a ball, work a pitch count, etc. Second, many of the players named in the Mitchell Report are scrubs - steroids didn't help them hit 50 home runs or clock 95 on their fastball.
Regarding the first point, here is a quote from Ken Caminiti (just one of a brilliant collection in http://www.baseballssteroidera.com):
"The stronger you get, the more relaxed you get. You feel good. You just let it fly. If you don't feel good, you try so hard to make something happen. You grip the bat harder and swing harder and that's when you tighten up. But you get that edge when you feel strong. That's the way I felt. I felt strong, like I could just try to meet the ball and -- wham! -- it's going to go 1,000 mph. Man, I felt good. I'd think, Damn, this pitcher's in trouble and I'd crush the ball 450 feet with almost no effort. It's all about getting an edge."
The second argument is really easy to deconstruct: we simply do not know how these players would have done had they not use steroids (assuming the allegations are true). The scrubs on the list may have never even made it to the major leagues without the extra jolt. Steroids likely provide a boost to players sitting at any level on the baseball skill distribution: they don't have to make you an all-star, but they may make you slightly better than you were before. In a competitive industry, this might be all the edge you need.
4) "The game of baseball has been denigrated" - Can anyone honestly tell me that this scandal, involving individuals cheating in order to perform better, is worse than the 1919 White Sox scandal and the match fixing scandal in international cricket where, in both cases, teams intentionally threw games? Sports have weathered these storms in the past. Baseball will be always popular and its heroes will come and go, steroids or not.
5) What to do now? - One the one hand, the Mitchell Report suggests stringent testing, harsher penalties and player education to stem the use of performance enhancing drugs in baseball. On the other hand, some analysts argue that it is impossible for testers to keep up with innovations in performance enhancers. After all, existing tests still cannot detect "the cream" and "the clear," substances Barry Bonds is suspected to have used. In fact, Marion Jones, who admitted using these products never tested positive, covering over 160 tests in sum. In this situation, these observers argue that legalizing these agents in the game and regulating their use with physician oversight might be a better way to go in terms of player health and leveling the playing field.
I'm not sure where I stand on this one, though I think I would lean towards trying to rid the sport of performance enhancing drugs. For one thing, I'm not really convinced by the "arms race" argument against more stringency. Following Gary Becker's seminal analysis on crime, suppose that the average player will use steroids if the expected benefits outweigh the expected costs. In this framework, expected costs are equal to the probability of being caught * the value of the costs themselves. Those who think we'll never catch steroid users believe the probabilities will be too low to give any bite to the costs. On the other hand, increasing penalties, publicly "outing" suspected users, and introducing uncertainty into Hall of Fame chances may jack up the costs enough to outweigh the lack of change in the probability. After all, do you think many players or managers are going to try and pull a Pete Rose now given all that he has been through? Social norms and pressure can be powerful and perhaps more stringency, then, could be a good policy to go with.
A thoughtful post by The Sports Economist provides more arguments for "cleaning up" baseball. One of the more interesting thoughts in that piece, which was alluded to earlier here, is that steroid use by a given MLB player has externalities: others will want to use it in order to compete and this will be true all the way down the pipeline. Where it becomes dangerous is at the level of younger people, who do not possess the resources to have a personal trainer monitor their use. This could have adverse health consequences both in the short and long run.
There is some evidence of noteworthy use of steroids in high school. This piece in JAMA suggests that almost 7% of high school senior athletes have used anabolic steroids. Of these, many started on their regimens as early as junior high. 7% seems like a pretty big number to me. What would be nice to have are figures relating likely steroid-driven adverse health events among this group and information on why these kids decided to initiate such regimens. That way we could get a sense of the extent to which externalities are operative in steroid use.
Friday, December 14, 2007
When Bad Inference Happens to Good People
I did a double take. Ron Dayne? An NFL journeyman with decent size, but limited speed, who is best utilized in a platoon of running backs? It turns out that the analyst was basing his comment on the following fact: the Texans are 4-1 in the past two seasons when Ron Dayne gets more than 20 carries.
This is another example of people confusing correlation for causation. There are two (or maybe more) explanations for the Ron Dayne tidbit:
1) Ron Dayne is a game changing talent who, if given the ball, will more often than not win the contest for you.
2) Ron Dayne getting 20 carries or so is a symptom of things working right offensively for the Texans. When the Texans are firing on all cylinders, Dayne's rushing opportunities and totals may reflect the fact that linebackers and safeties are playing off the line of scrimmage and drop back into coverage, allowing Dayne to get his 5-10 yard runs, or that offensive line play is so dominant that Dayne is able to run clear through the woods.
I think the second explanation is probably the more likely one. After all, can you imagine a defensive coordinator thinking before a game, "wow, we need to get 8 in the box to stop Ron Dayne"? Ron Dayne is a good player, but he's not LaDainian Tomlinson or even Frank Gore - the 2007 version.
In any case, this innocuous episode reflects the danger of attributing causal stories to what are only correlations. Unfortunately, fates of entire policies have hinged on bad inference, that too in arenas less trivial than professional sports.
Tuesday, November 27, 2007
How Can You Not Love Fantasy Football?
Just to put it in context, we have twelve teams in our league and six playoff spots. This is the final week of our regular season. Three teams (myself included) have clinched playoff spots and a whopping seven teams, all 6-6, are fighting for the other three.
Here goes:
I don't know if we've ever had a week as exciting as this right before the playoffs. Each of the 6-6 teams could end up in the playoffs.
Homechickens has to win to get the 1st round bye.
Hufflepuff and Bum Bum are playing for the first 1st round bye.
Then it gets really interesting.
Harmonica and FightingIrish control their own destiny and are into the playoffs with a win.
Regal, Detroit, Drunken, and Buckeye are also competing with each other for points scored this week b/c they are all within 40 pts. of each other.
dags needs to win and have DetroitLions4eva lose to make the playoffs.
It's pretty cool b/c everyone has something to play for.
Cheer for my team!
Sunday, November 25, 2007
Root for the Underdog of the Season!
Basically, as the "owner" of my team, I would fire myself as GM and Coach. I might as well set up the team and outsource all the decision making to someone who knows better.
Anyway, this season, with two games left in the regular season, I am sitting in second place at 8-3, having scored more points that each of the teams below me, and just five points off the pace of the first place squad. I've clinched a playoff spot, and I am hoping to win it all.
I think you should root for my team this year, especially because since my squad is the kind of underdog everyone would want to root for. Here is why:
1) I've overcome adversity at multiple points this season - I lost Ronnie Brown, who was an early season fantasy hoss, for the year, Jevon Walker for most of the season, and David Gerrard for a crucial four game stretch. Despite this, I keep winning. I attribute this to my unusually good waiver wire strategies (see 3).
2) My squad is made up of a lot of cast-offs and feel good stories - For example, my starting QBs are Jeff Garcia, a journeyman, elderly statesman, and David Gerrard, who wasn't even supposed to start when I drafted him. My backup QB is Vinny Testerverde, a guy my father remembers seeing play when he was in grad school. My second starting RB is Jesse Chatman, Ronnie Brown's replacement in Miami who kept getting kicked off of his past teams for being overweight. My defense was drawn entirely off the waiver wire (I missed the live draft when I was in South Africa). Finally, even my lovable uber-star, the incomparable LaDanian Tomlinson, is having an off year (by his standards, anyway).
3) The owner really needs this win - My college roommate, a three or four time champion, keeps pointing out how I've historically sucked at fantasy. In the past, other owners have criticized admittedly stupid roster moves I've made (for every mid season trade for Larry Johnson, I've drafted rookie WRs in the fourth round). I need to win both to earn respect and to offset what has been a ridiculously dry semester of research.
Also, did I mention that I haven't won a playoff game in nine years? There is only one way to describe that: hapless.
4) Finally, my team is named Hufflepuff's Cup, in honor of the kind but ultimately unremarkable Hogwarts House. Its funny how my team has turned out to be just like them: no stars, just solid performers who put their hearts and bodies on the line for me every week. How can you root against a team like that!?
So, for the next five weeks, root for Hufflepuff's Cup. It's like cheering for Rocky or those Chak De India girls: its a tough ride but, in the end, I think you'll be glad you stuck with 'em.
Wednesday, October 24, 2007
What's that 'Racquet'?
I was pretty crazy about tennis then, and my interests in the sport ranged from strategy to equipment. I was especially fanatic about the latter: I spent hours reading the yearly racquet- issue in Tennis magazine. This special issue was about twice as thick as a normal issue and catalogued every new stick released in the last year and some of the more popular sticks from years past. Each description had a picture of the racquet, its specs (swing weight, balance, string pattern, stiffness, etc), and a description of what the magazine staff thought of the stick. I think I was drawn to this because it was kind of science-y. Indeed, several of the descriptions would feature comments from an MIT engineering professor.
I bought two racquets during my high school tennis career: the Head Pro Tour 280 and the Head Radical Tour. The former is perhaps the best racquet I have ever played with: it truly felt like an extension of my right arm. I felt like I could do anything with the ball, short of cooking it and putting it in a sandwich. Kick serves, sharply angled backhands, low volleys, and funky slices were all within my reach. Sadly, this wonderful blue stick was discontinued just two years after being introduced into the market and mine was destroyed within two years of its purchase over a trip to India, where my little cousins used it as a trampoline, thus deadening the string bed/frame nexus. The Head Radical Tour was bought as the closest replacement I could find for the 280.
I've gotten some good mileage out of my Radical, but its been frustrating. In the back of my mind I knew that I had already found the perfect racquet for me and, the Head corporation's marketing decisions notwithstanding, I hadn't done enough to cultivate a continuing relationship with that particular piece of equipment. After all, I could have bought two (or three) racquets instead of one. Or I could have been more vigilant in keeping it out of the hands of unwitting toddlers. Regrets, regrets: I could have tried so much harder!
A few weeks ago, after having played only sporadically in college, medical and grad school, I decided to get serious about tennis again. While playing with one of my mates, my trusty but ultimately unexciting Radical broke, the butt cap coming free from the handle. I took it to the pro shop to see if I could get it fixed but deep down I knew the thing was dead.
Given the inevitable, I was now racquet-less. I did the first thing I could think of: I went to eBay and some of the online tennis wholesalers to see if I could find a still unused Pro Tour 280. No luck. I lamented to the pro shop proprieter. He told me to get over it, dry my eyes, and move on. Racquet technology has really improved and perhaps I'll find a good fit in some of the new stuff?
One thing led to another, and I ended up joining his demo program. This is basically like a tennis racquet library: you borrow two racquets at a time and try them out. Based on what you tell the pro, he'll set you up with sticks that might work for your style of play (swing speed, court positioning, weaknesses, etc). I went home with the Babolat Aero Storm and Head Radical Tour Pro Microgel.
I was skeptical. My first impression was that racquet demo-ing was that this was like speed dating (which I have never tried - this is not the first time in this blog where I've discussed something I know nothing about): you get a few moments to make a decision on whether you want another go with the person or racquet. On the one hand, a few moments sounds like a crock: what if you happen to have an unusually great day when you hit with a racquet thats not quite right? On the other hand, Malcolm Gladwell talks about the power of first impressions in Blink, where even 30 seconds might be plenty of time to distill the situation and figure things out.
In any case, my skepticism probably came out of some need to make excuses for not wanting to try something new: I already found the right racquet years ago, and now its no longer possible to purchase that particular stick. Whats the point of working so hard to find something that I believe won't be as good? Why go through the disappointment? I even ignored the fact that I made my decision to buy the Pro Tour 280 with even less information: my choice was purely based on a quarter page blurb in Tennis that I read over and over.
Well, I'm happy to report that the Babolat Aero Storm has blown me away. Its 98 square inches and 11.7 ounces of ridiculously good control and spin. I can sit back and swing away, and still keep everything in the court. My volleys are crisp and the slices stay low. I absolutely love the stick. I am currently testing out the Technofibre Tfight 325 and some gimmicky Prince racquet that I can't stand. I kind of like the Technofibre, too, but I think the Babolat's the one.
So, over 10 years later, I finally found a racquet that really works (and is popular enough not to be discontinued). I'm really looking forward to the winter season, where I plan on playing team tennis. Who knows: maybe I'll get back to a solid 4.5-5.0 and enter tournaments again. Right now, though, its just nice to know that, after so many years, I found a stick that jives with me.
Monday, September 10, 2007
In Purgatory with Larry Summers (or 'I am not Sexist')
Other person: Why don't women play five set matches?
Me: I don't think consumers want to see best of five women's matches. They wouldn't be very interesting, especially given the lack of depth on the women's circuit.
How was that sexist? I was just calling it the way I see it. Was there anything in my statement that indicated that I thought women were inferior or something? No.
Just for the record, when the women's tour was sponsored by the cigarette manufacturer Virginia Slims, the year end tournament (kinda like the men's Tennis Masters) had five-set matches. Only one match ever went to five sets, and the majority of the other matches were brutally uninteresting (see here). Which brings up the point: if there was demand for longer women's matches, wouldn't we be seeing more of these, rather than the elimination of any existing five-setters? And no, I don't think a market failure argument works in the TV sports world.
This is the second time I've been accused of being sexist. The last incident was in 1991, when my sixth grade teacher got really mad at me for asking my mom to bring me a book that I forgot at home. "Why didn't you ask your dad to bring the book?" asked my teacher, while delivering a glowering look.
I was too afraid to explain my side: "Well, gee, my dad is at work right now, about 30 minutes a way, and my mom is at home, about 2 minutes away. And heck, my dad would be totally clueless about my textbooks, anyway."
I have a great deal of respect for women's rights and the feminist movement. What I have no patience for are the over-sensitive elements that sit around and get offended at perfectly reasonable arguments, such as why most people would get bored watching five sets of women's tennis (I'm sorry, but that's just true). And using emotionally charged terms like "sexist" in inappropriate contexts is just a lame thing to do. Save it for when it really matters.
A digression: Ok, I agree that there are some men out there who are total pigs. But most of us aren't. Kudos to the people who recognize that. And, trust me, there are people like that. I went to an AIDS-related protest in Cape Town a few weeks back (check this space in the next few days for more on that), and one of the groups represented was a women's rights outfit. The woman who was representing the group began her speech with stories about rape, disrespect and infidelity, all forces that bring HIV/AIDS to innocent women all over Africa who definitely deserve better.
But before she went off lambasting men, the speaker paused and said:
"Give a hand to all the enlightened and good men out there that understand our plight and fight with us."
Thank you.
Thursday, September 6, 2007
Andre Agassi and Great Analysts
I really enjoyed last night’s Federer-Roddick match. For one thing, it was pretty amazing to watch Roddick play his absolute best and still lose to someone who is capable of raising his game to ridiculous levels. (How does someone make returning a 140 MPH serve look that easy!) This was a feast of really high quality tennis, and that, too, served with an excellent side-dish: Andre Agassi’s commentary.
Tuesday, August 14, 2007
Indian Cricket, the BCCI and the ICL, by Maheer Gandhavadi
I love sports. Most of my time on the internet is devoted to various sports websites and my morning routine is not complete without some Sportscenter and cereal. If I had to rank sports in terms of the enjoyment I derive from them, American football would be on top and cricket would be second.
Cricket receives little attention from people here in the US - most of thetime people think I'm referring to croquet - and its hard to find fault with this. In the original (test match) form of the game, matches take FIVE DAYS to complete. The truncated (one day international = ODI) version only takes 1 day. And by one day I mean 8 hours or more. When you consider the length of matches and the often perplexing rules, it's no wonder that baseball, the godson of cricket, is preferred in this country and that cricket remains relegated to England and its former colonies.
In the past few years, however, there has been a push to make cricket more accessible with the introduction of Twenty20 cricket. Twenty20 cricket features matches that last 2.5-3 hours, about the length of a baseball/football game. So far Twenty20 matches have been very popular and have been growing in number.
*****
Although the national sport of India is field hockey, cricket is by far its most popular sport. Indians devour anything cricket related, and the Indian cricket market is the largest in the world. Indian cricket fans are rabid ;after Bangladesh defeated India in a World Cup match earlier this year, infuriated fans destroyed bowler Zaheer Khan's restaurant in Pune and wicketkeeper MS Dhoni's house in Ranchi (note: I do not condone this behavior in any way or form, it just serves as an example).
The record of the Indian cricket team has been stellar in the sub-continent; they are essentially unbeatable. However their results overseas are another story. Out of 200 test matches played abroad, India has won 29. TWENTY NINE! That is ridiculous.
*****
Cricket in India is ruled by one body, aptly named the Board of Control forCricket in India. They decide what the match schedule for the Indian team, they select the players on the national team, they set the pay scale for theplayers. They also control various cricket fixtures and tournaments within India. The BCCI is basically this big bureaucracy that is in charge of anything associated with cricket in India.
Not surprisingly, the BCCI is India's richest sporting body and perhaps the richest cricket sporting body in the world. Let's look at a few of their contracts:
-kit sponsorship deal with Nike from 2006-2010: US$43 million
-official team sponsorship with Air Sahara over 4 years: US$70 million
-media rights for 25 neutral venue ODIs to Zee TV: US$219.15 million
-global media rights for cricket in India over 2006-2010 to Nimbus: $612million!
Bottom line: the BCCI is loaded. Their net worth is well over US$1 billion,which is an incredible sum for any sports agency worldwide and especially large by Indian standards.
****
What the BCCI's financial success reflects, more than anything else, is the fervor with which Indians pursue cricket. Again, Indians love cricket. They worship the sport. Is it too much to ask, therefore, for Indian success at home and abroad? Can anyone truly be satisfied with the team going from a king in South Asia to a doormat anywhere else? One would think that a nation of 1 billion people (most of whom play and watch cricket almost all the time) would be able to produce players capable of executing in any environment.
Fed up with the state of cricket in India (and no doubt looking to make a nice profit) Subash Chandra, head of Zee TV, announced the creation of the Indian Cricket League (ICL) in April 2007. All ICL matches are to be played in the new Twenty20 format. Moreover, the teams will be comprised of four international, two Indian, and eight rising domestic players. Cricketsuperstars such as Brian Lara, Shane Warne, Glenn McGrath, and Inzamam Ul-Haq, players who remain popular but whose skills are not entirely on par with international cricket standards, have expressed interest in joining theICL.
The ICL seems to have it all - an entertaining format, veteran players who can attract a crowd, and a way in which unknown Indian players can gain national exposure. Not surprisingly, the BCCI has taken a clear anti-ICL stand, going so far as to say that any players involved in the ICL would bebanned from cricket FOR LIFE.
*****
What gives?
From the BCCI's standpoint this makes perfect sense. They have a monopoly on cricket in India and can easily use their size and power to push any potential rivals out of their market. The BCCI could even go so far as to create its own Twenty20 league to rival the ICL. I understand where theboard is coming from and if I was the BCCI I would be tempted to do something similar if my profits were at stake.
However, as a cricket fan, I find this appalling. The BCCI is full of a bunch of obnoxious, overbearing jerks. They're also self-serving. Every team selection and action undertaken by the board is riddled with politics. It's just ridiculous. On our current team, there are multiple players whose skills have diminished and should just make way for a younger breed. Yet they continue to play. Also, is Anil Kumble really the only spinner inIndia? Yeesh.
In terms of its sheer bureaucracy-ness the BCCI is just over the top. If I had to point to one reason why the Indian team is so stagnant, it would be the BCCI.
The current state of cricket in India is most analogous to the Indian economy post independence (1947). The post-1947 economy was full of regulations and bureaucracy, in part out of fears of another East India Company taking over the country. As a result of these regulations, overall growth was minimal. Only in the 1990s when regulations were lifted and the government decided to pursue a much more open market approach did the economy flourish and achieve the remarkable growth rates we see today.
The BCCI should adopt a similar free market approach. Why restrict the ICL? If it is a product that the people want then the BCCI should strive to meet these demands as well. And the selection process for the national team should follow the Australian method. That is, it should be totally merit based. If you aren't playing well, you aren't on the team. No questions asked. Will this make a difference? I don't know. But, I would be happy to know that our best team was on the field at all times.
One final note to those at the BCCI, I will definitely be watching the ICL when it starts.